Mi nyag bla ma ye shes rdo rje: Difference between revisions

From Tsadra Commons
Mi nyag bla ma ye shes rdo rje
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 16: Line 16:
|BdrcLink=https://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=P9718
|BdrcLink=https://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=P9718
|BnwShortPersonBio=Yeshe Dorje (born fourteenth century) from Minyak in Kham was a student of the Karma Kamtsang master Mase Tönpa Rinchen Zangpo (1317–1383), the second Gangkar Lama. The latter is known as one of "the five learned ones from Minyak" and was a student of the Third and Fourth Karmapas, Dölpopa, Butön, and several Kadampa masters. (Adapted from ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 309)
|BnwShortPersonBio=Yeshe Dorje (born fourteenth century) from Minyak in Kham was a student of the Karma Kamtsang master Mase Tönpa Rinchen Zangpo (1317–1383), the second Gangkar Lama. The latter is known as one of "the five learned ones from Minyak" and was a student of the Third and Fourth Karmapas, Dölpopa, Butön, and several Kadampa masters. (Adapted from ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 309)
|PosBuNayDefProv=Definitive
|PosBuNayDefProvNotes="In particular, YDC refutes that the teaching on the tathāgata heart is one that bears an intention because its claimed bases of intention are not tenable, its purpose is not established, and there is no invalidation of this teaching." [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 310.
|PosAllBuddha=Yes
|PosAllBuddhaMoreNotes="YDC clearly subscribes to the disclosure model of buddha nature, asserting that the stainless tathāgata heart adorned with all major and minor marks as well as awakening exists in all beings, refuting that the reality of cessation is a nonimplicative negation, and denying the position that the fully qualified sugata heart exists solely on the buddhabhūmi, while it is only nominal at the time of sentient beings." [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 310.
|PosWheelTurn=Third Turning
|PosWheelTurnNotes=However, his work has an interesting approach to the second and third wheel turnings:
" The second dharma wheel is said to teach primarily the way in which the phenomena of which the basis of emptiness is empty do not exist, while the third wheel teaches mainly that basis of emptiness. Therefore, there is no inner contradiction between these two dharma wheels." [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 310.
|PosYogaMadhya=Madhyamaka
|PosYogaMadhyaNotes="YDC denies that the ''Uttaratantra'' is a work that belongs to Mere Mentalism." [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 310.
|PosZhenRang=Rangtong
|PosZhenRangNotes=It is not entirely clear that he would identify with the Rangtong view, but he seems to have issues with Zhentong, as Brunnhölzl points out:
"Also, the emptiness taught in the buddha nature sūtras and the Uttaratantra is not "the emptiness of one’s being empty of something other," which is said to be the worst kind of emptiness in the Laṅkāvatārasūtra, but corresponds to this sūtra’s 'great ultimate emptiness of the wisdom of the noble ones.'"  [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 310.
|PosAnalyticMedit=Analytic Tradition
|PosAnalyticMeditNotes=The lineage included within his work on the ''Uttaratantra'' passes through Ngok and others who upheld his tradition.
See [[Brunnhölzl, K.]], ''[[When the Clouds Part]]'', p. 309.
|IsInGyatsa=No
|IsInGyatsa=No
}}
}}

Revision as of 10:37, 14 August 2018

PersonType Category:Classical Tibetan Authors
MainNamePhon Minyak Lama Yeshe Dorje
MainNameTib མི་ཉག་བླ་མ་ཡེ་ཤེས་རྡོ་རྗེ་
MainNameWylie mi nyag bla ma ye shes rdo rje
AltNamesTib ཡེ་ཤེས་རྡོ་རྗེ་དཔལ་བཟང་པོ་
AltNamesWylie ye shes rdo rje dpal bzang po
AltNamesOther Yeshé Dorje  ·  Yeshé Dorje Bal Sangpo
YearBirth 14th Century
ReligiousAffiliation Kadam
StudentOf Rma se ston pa rin chen bzang po  ·  Third Karmapa Rangjung Dorje  ·  Fourth Karmapa Rolpai Dorje  ·  bu ston rin chen grub
BDRC https://www.tbrc.org/#!rid=P9718
IsInGyatsa No
BnwShortPersonBio Yeshe Dorje (born fourteenth century) from Minyak in Kham was a student of the Karma Kamtsang master Mase Tönpa Rinchen Zangpo (1317–1383), the second Gangkar Lama. The latter is known as one of "the five learned ones from Minyak" and was a student of the Third and Fourth Karmapas, Dölpopa, Butön, and several Kadampa masters. (Adapted from When the Clouds Part, p. 309)
PosBuNayDefProv Definitive
PosBuNayDefProvNotes "In particular, YDC refutes that the teaching on the tathāgata heart is one that bears an intention because its claimed bases of intention are not tenable, its purpose is not established, and there is no invalidation of this teaching." Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 310.
PosAllBuddha Yes
PosAllBuddhaMoreNotes "YDC clearly subscribes to the disclosure model of buddha nature, asserting that the stainless tathāgata heart adorned with all major and minor marks as well as awakening exists in all beings, refuting that the reality of cessation is a nonimplicative negation, and denying the position that the fully qualified sugata heart exists solely on the buddhabhūmi, while it is only nominal at the time of sentient beings." Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 310.
PosWheelTurn Third Turning
PosWheelTurnNotes However, his work has an interesting approach to the second and third wheel turnings:

" The second dharma wheel is said to teach primarily the way in which the phenomena of which the basis of emptiness is empty do not exist, while the third wheel teaches mainly that basis of emptiness. Therefore, there is no inner contradiction between these two dharma wheels." Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 310.

PosYogaMadhya Madhyamaka
PosYogaMadhyaNotes "YDC denies that the Uttaratantra is a work that belongs to Mere Mentalism." Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 310.
PosZhenRang Rangtong
PosZhenRangNotes It is not entirely clear that he would identify with the Rangtong view, but he seems to have issues with Zhentong, as Brunnhölzl points out:

"Also, the emptiness taught in the buddha nature sūtras and the Uttaratantra is not "the emptiness of one’s being empty of something other," which is said to be the worst kind of emptiness in the Laṅkāvatārasūtra, but corresponds to this sūtra’s 'great ultimate emptiness of the wisdom of the noble ones.'" Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 310.

PosAnalyticMedit Analytic Tradition
PosAnalyticMeditNotes The lineage included within his work on the Uttaratantra passes through Ngok and others who upheld his tradition.

See Karl Brunnhölzl, When the Clouds Part, p. 309.

Other wikis